Leader: Time to kick Fifa’s rules into touch

Wednesday 9th November 2011, 10:59AM GMT.

Leader: Time to kick Fifa’s rules into touch

Just days before Remembrance Day, Fifa has given a disgusting slap in the face to all the fallen heroes of this nation who fought for freedom.

The FA’s request for the England team to be allowed to wear poppies on their shirts during Saturday’s encounter with Spain was an entirely reasonable one.

It is as far away as thrusting some unacceptable and arrogant national symbol down the throats of other countries as it could be. The poppy is a discreet and traditional mark of respect to honour the sacrifices of those without whom some of the footballing nations of the world today would be playing with swastikas on their shirts.

The poppy is a badge to be worn with pride for a one-off occasion.

Yet Fifa has banned it on the grounds that shirts should not carry “political, religious, or commercial messages”.

The poppy is none of these things.

They are more on a par with black armbands worn at times of tragedy and mourning. Bizarrely, it seems likely that England players will be wearing these armbands during the match in lieu of the banned poppies.

Faced with a diktat from football’s ruling body, England now has what looks on the surface like a difficult decision, but which is not really difficult at all when you consider what the poppy really stands for – selfless sacrifices in the cause of freedom.

Listen to the voices of the fallen. They did not bend the knee. Nor should England on Saturday. And if Fifa calls the game off, as it has threatened to, so be it – England will have honoured the memories of those who died fighting the monstrously unreasonable.

England v Spain on Saturday. Wear the poppy. With pride.

Patients tell true story:

There are two versions of the National Health Service.

There is the NHS of waiting times, performance tables, leagues, and politically motivated use of statistics to prove this or that point.

And then there are the anecdotes of ordinary people who spend time in hospital.

Today’s dossier from the Patients Association detailing shameful stories about the care elderly patients receive in England NHS hospitals is a real aid to understanding.

Statistics can disguise almost anything. Except the story of an old man left to sit in his own faeces, or the cancer patient dying in agony because staff were slow to administer pain relief.

There have been cases in which families have been so unhappy about the level of care that they have brought their loved ones out of hospital.

It should be acknowledged that there will be many patients who experience excellent care.

The association’s dossier has led to the standard smooth assurances that the NHS is working to improve matters.

Maybe there will be statistics soon to back that up.

But the best indication of improvement will be when the only stories coming from patients are positive stories.


  1. 1
    Bob dobbs

    The FA have blown this completely out of proportion and typically our media and king of Bandwagon jumping David Cameron has weighed in to this argument to point out how disgraceful this ‘poppy ban’ is.

    The simple fact of the matter is that FIFA do not allow national, political or pseudo-political logos on the shirts. While I would never agree the Poppy should be classed as national or political it is simply falling foul of these rules. The FA KNEW this when they asked, they knew what the answer was going to be but they still did it.

    The ‘tradition’ of wearing Poppies on football shirts isn’t a tradition at all, and only dates back about 5 years. On the 10th November 2001 England played Sweden at home and there wasn’t a Poppy or black armband in sight, if I recall correctly there was a minutes silence before the game but nothing compared to what the FA want to do to show their ‘respect’ this year.

    The criticism of FIFA by the FA is nothing short of an attempt to further their disharmony with the Football governing body, and subsequent Cameron and British media bandwagon jumping has lapped it up.

    It is not FIFA’s (clear but perhaps a tad unreasonable) rules that is an affront to our glorious dead, but the actions of the FA to stir this situation up. If they really cared about the campaign at all they would hand over ALL the proceeds of Saturday’s game (which lets face it, is a money making friendly if ever there was one) to the British Legion.

    While the Royal British Legions’ Poppy campaign is a discreet and honourable one, the FA’s use of this issue to further their fight with FIFA (and no doubt promote Saturday’s game) is nothing short of crass and dishonourable.

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    James

    My first reaction when I heard this story was that FIFA would do better to try rooting out corruption in their ranks or asking themselves why they gave the 2022 World Cup to an utterly unsuitable country than interfere in a matter like this.

    But I also agree with Bob Dobbs. The poppy is indeed a discreet, poignant symbol of sacrifice – or at least it used to be before it got hijacked by the celebrity, media and political fraternity as a ‘look at me’ statement.

    I also think that if the FA were truly keen to honour the fallen, they would have done better not to play the match at all or at least given all the proceeds to the British Legion or other ex-servicemens charity. An England game, with its overhyped millionaire players is anything but a discreet medium through which to show remembrance.

    The FA have contrived the situation and our PM has used it – in both cases for their own glorification. Shame on them, because they’re in danger of ensuring that the real heroism, the sacrifices and the all-round tragedy that is war are in danger of being forgotten.

    Report abuse



Free e-Supplements

TWITTER

Shropshire Star on Twitter Shropshire Star on Twitter

Keep updated with the latest breaking news and content on our Twitter feed.

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Shropshire Star and Express & Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

Entertainment

All the film reviews All the film reviews

Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases.

OUR NEW APP

Get the new Shropshire Star app Get the new Shropshire Star app

Download the Shropshire Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.