Blog: American recycling is better than Shropshire’s
Friday 28th October 2011, 10:00AM BST.
Blog: Rubbish in the bin or trash in the cart? Either way it appears Shropshire has it tough, writes county expat Mark Ellis from his home in Arizona.
For the past six years I have worked for a large waste management company whichcollects rubbish from homes and businesses and owns many transfer stations, recycling facilities and landfills.
It is not the biggest waste company in the US, but let’s just say it is the best.
I bring this up because I have read in the Shropshire Star about the rubbish police photographing bins, incinerator arguments, and most recently Shropshire Council’s decision to end cardboard collection with garden waste.
Living in Scottsdale I recognise that I am spoiled in many ways but I had never really considered the mundane task of putting out my rubbish as being one of them.
I have two large wheelie bins, a pink one for recycling and a black one for all other non-hazardous household and garden waste, both of which are emptied once a week.
There are a few things that can’t go in the recycling bin, but generally any domestic rubbish that can be recycled is thrown in, from newspaper to cardboard, glass to plastic, aluminium and metal cans, the list goes on……
What doesn’t go in the pink bin goes in the black one. Simple.
Many local councils in the UK don’t appear to be getting the message that if you want people to recycle you have to make it straightforward, not a chore.
If I had to separate my recyclables into half a dozen different bins, boxes and bags I am pretty sure my black bin would be much fuller every week.
It’s not that the average Joe doesn’t want to recycle, re-use, and re-purpose to avoid filling our landfills, it’s that there is a limit to the amount of time and effort that he is willing to donate to the cause.
The company I work for invests millions of dollars a year to improve our ability to extract recyclable materials from the waste stream and they do it for a couple of reasons.
First, as a company we have to be as environmentally responsible as possible and be seen to encourage and enable our customers to act in a similarly green manner.
Then, there is a massive amount of money to be made from selling reclaimed materials such as aluminium, cardboard, paper, and building materials.
As a company we sell the materials collected from our customers to mills both here in the US and in other countries, mainly China.
We don’t keep all the proceeds from selling the materials. Our commercial customers get rebates based on the amount of recycled materials we collect from their locations and sell.
And we are starting programs where residential customers get recycling credits that can be exchanged for goodies.
I have never seen any discussion around the concept of single-stream recycling in the Shropshire Star. This is the simple approach we have here in Scottsdale – throw everything into one bin and let machinery separate it into the different types of materials at a recycling centre.
This is in stark contrast to the pre-sorted approach found in most parts of Shropshire.
My parents in Lower Frankton and mother-in-law in Cockshutt have shared stories of their rubbish not being removed because there was something in the wrong bin, or they inadvertently put out the wrong coloured box, or incorrectly shaped bag, on the wrong day, or didn’t put anything out when they should’ve so it couldn’t be collected.
It’s crazy. How much time is wasted, and at what cost, by residents and refuse workers? Probably enough to fund a couple of automated single-stream recycling centres every year if it were eliminated.
One bin for recycling, another for non-hazardous household rubbish – it’s really not that difficult. Call your local council and ask why they can’t or won’t do it.
Then ask them what they do with all the money they make from selling the recycled materials and maybe suggest they use some of it to make your life a little easier.
Shropshire Star on Twitter
Keep updated with the latest breaking news and content on our Twitter feed.
Lifestyle
Interactive Dining Out map
Hundreds of reviews by the Shropshire Star and Express & Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.
Entertainment
All the film reviews
Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases.
OUR NEW APP
Get the new Shropshire Star app
Download the Shropshire Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.

Recycling is better in Cambridgeshire than it is in Shropshire!
After moving to Cambridge from Shropshire recently I really don’t miss the ’5′ different and ridiculous recycling containers – On recycling days I would have up to 25 containers at the end of my drive from the 4 other houses and mine and if it was a windy day after collection it was a nightmare.
Now I only have three wheeled bins, one for garden waste, one for household waste and one for everything recylable – If Cambs can do it why can’t Shropshire, would it be money by any chance!?
Report abuse
A very interesting article. I also live in the US (Pennsylvania) Like the UK it depends very much where you live.
We have the old fashioned style bins which the householder owns plus a small green square bin for recycle waste. We have two collections a week. The first collection, on a Tuesday is for general waste and recycleable waste. On a friday there is a second collection for general waste and almost anything else including items of furniture etc.
I can’t say this is a great environmentally friendly service but it’s frequent and I don’t have the hassle that people in Shropshire have.
I rather suspect the British system is dictated by the dictators in Brussels
Report abuse
But how much does this cost? We’re constantly being told we have to reduce the deficit, councils are having their budget cuts frontloaded so how are we to pay for other countries or armies of workers here to sort through our rubbish when we can do it at for free with not that much real difficulty? I can think of other things I’d prefer the money to be spent on.
Report abuse
Grey,
Who suggested we pay other countries or armies of workers to sort our rubbish?
There are very effective machines to sort recyclables with limited human intervention. Sure they are expensive but the ROI is short.
The goal is to get everyone to recycle as opposed to the few that can be bothered with the PITA process you currently have to go through.
Commodities are valuable and becoming more so with time, why throw them into a landfill or incinerator?
Report abuse
There was a programme on TV the other day about automated single-stream recycling centres, and the problem with these is that they often leave bundles with some other items mixed in, as the system hasn’t sorted them out 100%. Thus a paper bundle will end up useless as it still has some plastic or other materials mixed in, so it gets sent back or sent to China.
Report abuse
Re: Single-stream…
From my limited understanding of the way current recycling works, machines would do a *much* better job that leaving it to Joe Public… There are too many rules concerning what goes where, which bin is which (although I am now informed our recycling boxes will all be black).
Without prejudice, the guys who collect the recycled waste in Shrewsbury don’t look to me to be the brightest of sparks, and they’re surely not qualified metallurgists or forensically trained enough to decide who is putting the correct waste in the correct boxes.
In the long run, a single recycling ‘bin’ which is emptied into a single container in a single truck makes a heck of a lot of sense.
Here’s a genuine tale of a LOCAL ‘environmental’ waste company…
My brother runs a large commercial printing company in Shrewsbury, and as such they generate a lot of paper waste. Rather than discard with the usual business waste, they decided to employ Company X to recycle it. While they were at it, they also used Company X to take away their general business waste.
The result was two identical large container skips, collected weekly. And at some considerable cost.
Due to the size of the containers, neither was entirely filled during the week. In fact, they remained half-full frequently.
On one collection day during summer, the factory loading bay was open, and the staff observed the collection of both containers. By a single vehicle. Into the same collection area. Mixed.
Upon commenting to the vehicle operators, my brother was told “Yes, it all goes to the same place in the same truck. The stuff is sorted at the depot.”.
After which point, the recycling bin was cancelled, and all waste was placed in the same container from that point forward.
So, this kind of ‘whitewashing’ the underlying problem to make it *seem* that “THE PUBLIC MUST ALSO DO THEIR PART” is absolute crud.
My wife and myself are avid recyclers. We religiously separate our waste, we strategically bundle parcels of paper, clothing etc. to take to relevant recycling departments of supermarkets/collection points.
However, are we all wasting our time?
Single-stream recycling seems to be a huge leap forward. From what I’ve seen it’s quite efficient—moreso than most householders who literally just use the recycling boxes as extra refuse containers (I’ve even noted them being used for shopping and storage).
As we can never expect to get a straight answer on this, and there is never going to be a full resolve, we only have conclusions based on observation to make our own minds up. Look around your locality and the driveways of the public on Recycling Collection days… the real truth is painfully obvious.
Report abuse