Blog: Have we sold out small towns to supermarket domination?
Tuesday 26th April 2011, 9:05AM BST.
Blog: When I moved to Powys, Welshpool became my nearest town and I was more than happy with that, writes Emma Suddaby.
It’s a charming old town with plenty of small, interesting shops, and bigger ones too if you’re in need of a supermarket. It boasts a sweet, canalside walk right in the town centre, Powis Castle is not much further should you fancy a bit of culture, and a newly revived weekly street market for everything else.
Being disabled, I have to try to park right outside whichever shop I need and it’s never been too much of a struggle in lovely old Welshpool.
And then Tesco came to town.
I almost hate to write about them because I find myself doing it so often – am I obsessed with Tesco or are they really trying to take over the world?
Their latest bid for world domination has seen them build a new superstore bang in the middle of poor Welshpool, with more parking, bigger windows and cheaper deals than anything the small traders of the town could ever hope to offer.
And then, to top it all off, the traffic system has been re-arranged, apparently to improve access and traffic flow past the new store. I have nothing against the new one-way system in theory. It should, and could, work.
But the reality is that a large percentage of the town’s through traffic is now directed conveniently past the new store to sit in the tedious traffic jams, which culminate right outside the Tesco entrance – until even the staunchest of anti-superstore folk amongst drivers must find themselves wondering if it wouldn’t be quicker to just pop into Tesco and do the shopping there.
Call me cynical, but since Tesco came to town, it takes twice as long to drive through the town centre, with unfamiliar drivers flouting lanes left right and centre due to poorly signed routes, and I can’t park where I need to for love, money nor disabled badges.
And that’s just from the driver’s perspective. What about those small, interesting shops, how long will it be before they can no longer compete with the money-off vouchers and the two-for-one deals and the easy parking offered by the new “big boy” in town?
I firmly believe that one day we will all wake up and realise that we’ve slept too deeply, allowing our town councils and planning departments to be seduced by chains and, in doing so, have signed the death warrant for lovely old towns like Welshpool.
Give me small shops and character and freedom of choice – I’ve got a BOGOF offer for Tesco’s but I’m not sure they’d want it!
Shropshire Star on Twitter
Keep updated with the latest breaking news and content on our Twitter feed.
Lifestyle
Interactive Dining Out map
Hundreds of reviews by the Shropshire Star and Express & Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.
Entertainment
All the film reviews
Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases.
OUR NEW APP
Get the new Shropshire Star app
Download the Shropshire Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.
The large supermarket chains now have a stranglehold on most towns and cities.
It has sounded the death knell for for small independent shops who can’t hope to compete on price or selection of products.
Maggie Thatcher said “Britain is a nation of shopkeepers” not for much longer I fear.
What we are seeing is the changing face of Britain,not sure if it’s a good or bad thing.
Report abuse
Cheap food = Good thing.
Report abuse
Cheap food = farmers going out of business and Britain being dependant on foreign price fluctuations
Report abuse
This is an excellent example of why the average Joe should take an interest in local politics and planning. We all have a voice in what is approved or rejected – use it.
Just to be contrarian, would it have been better for the Tesco’s to have been built a mile outside the town centre? Had that been the case there would be no traffic in the town and the small shops would have zero chance of surviving. Just saying.
Report abuse
One word – Madeley.
Report abuse
Another word – what?
Report abuse
Improved x10
Report abuse
Having paid £1 admission to Morrisons car park and then been refused a refund because I only bought a Shropshire Star I say thank you to Tesco for moving in, perhaps it will wake the others up. parking in the town is not usually as easy as your previous writer suggests and on my [ fortnightly ] visits to Powys I can rarely park on the main street. I think that the main traders to suffer will be the other supermarkets and it serves them right as they buy in the same market as Tesco and should compete rather than making excess profits their primary motive.I would certainly never go to Tesco for meat in preference to the main butcher in town and , as regards essentials such as wine , bread etc there is a little shop in LLanfair which competes with them all .
Report abuse
Serves you right for moving to Powys
Report abuse
They are cheep on some things but it’s all false economy. you get what you pay for.
I dislike the way they treat their suppliers like dirt. Demanding more for less. They are bad for the long term economy but they don’t care as long as they continue to dominate our towns.
Report abuse
Tesco has even more dominance after quietly taking ownership of the Dillons / One Stop chain of convenience shops from T&N Stores Ltd.
Welshpool in fact has two Tescos!
The take-over of One Stop Stores should have been vetoed at the time by the Competition Commission.
Since then, Tesco has used its One Stop subsidiary to acquire even more convenience stores from other businesses. In a controversial deal, Tesco recently bought 77 convenience stores from the Mills Group.
Through its latest acquisitions, Tesco now operates three stores in Ludlow, all within a few hundred yards of each other.
Tesco isn’t even pretending to run the One Stop chain profitably.
Although 100% owned by Tesco, the One Stop stores continue to operate separately, using different suppliers, management structure, etc.
Tesco’s long-term plans for its One Stop stores remain a mystery.
What is clear is that Tesco has acquired land and property for predatory reasons: to kill off competition and to prevent rivals from building their own stores.
Report abuse
Forgive me for asking, but, you’re not a conspiracy theorist by any chance are you?
And just an aside, I still think the Competition Commission sounds lame, the MMC sounded sooo much better. Should have left the name the same and given them the same powers.
Report abuse
“Forgive me for asking, but, you’re not a conspiracy theorist by any chance are you?”
Don’t shoot the messenger!!
Report abuse
2 powys towns have been killed by Tesco – Newtown and Welshpool. Well done councillors – enjoy your miserable choices and performance in serving your community – you deserve all you get
Report abuse
OH look what’s beside this article – an advert for Tesco !
Report abuse
‘Going local’ is a powerful strategy to help repair our fractured world – our ecosystems, our societies and our selves. Far from the old institutions of power, people are starting to forge a very different future…see http://www.theeconomicsofhappiness.org/
Report abuse
Local people clearly prefer Tesco and should not be deprived of the value everyone else in the country gets. Local traders need to buck up their ideas and compete on service and quality. It may take a while but if there is a market for quality then new local shops should be able to provide this – if threre isnt then let the professionls (Tesco) do what they do best.
Report abuse
At least Tesco try to improve the local area such as in Madeley.In that respect they are at least better than some other supermarkets like Asda/Wal-Mart.
Report abuse