Catholic church child abuse scandal outweighs the good

Monday 20th September 2010, 11:30AM BST.

Former Archbishop of Westminster Cormac Murphy O'Connor (left) and current Archbishop of Westminster Vincent Nichols (second left) watch as Pope Benedict XVI leads a Prayer Vigil at Hyde Park in London, on the third day of his State Visit.
Former Archbishop of Westminster Cormac Murphy O'Connor (left) and current Archbishop of Westminster Vincent Nichols (second left) watch as Pope Benedict XVI leads a Prayer Vigil at Hyde Park in London, on the third day of his State Visit.

Well I know there are many out there looking for employment right now, but just thank your lucky stars it’s not your job to sort out the Pope’s PR, that’s one vacancy that could remain unfilled for some time, writes Shropshire Star blogger Emma Suddaby.

Three mass vigils planned for last week to mark the Pope’s visit to Britain did not sell out, with thousands of Catholics snubbing the events over the child abuse scandals which have rocked the church.

I am not a Catholic, although I did attend a Catholic Convent for my schooling. Unfortunately, the experience was enough to put me off organised religion for life, though that’s not to say I don’t have a faith.

My school was, of course, largely run by nuns and priests. Like most things in life, there were good ones and there were bad ones and we learnt pretty quickly, to tell one from the other.

But the very fact that I went through a highly religious educational environment and came out the other end saying I’ve kept my faith despite attending a convent, indicates a problem somewhere along the line.

I heard a priest telling of his training at the Vatican. He said he had gone into the city one night wearing his priestly robes and some kids, playing in the street had called “paedophile!”‘ at him as he passed.

He was terribly upset but the truth is that we have been hearing the horrible details of child abuse within the church for such a long time now that the negative aspects of religion have started to outweigh the positive.

In an age where we are allowed, even encouraged to ask questions the church’s refusal to hear them, let alone answer them, is the reason so many are turning away from organised religion.

We live in an age of transparency, where ordinary people expect access to all areas of life. We want to be given the facts, not told to look the other way while they are swept under the carpet.

And if the Pope himself is guilty of wielding the biggest broom of all, what belief can we possibly have in the integrity of the rest of the church?

So I am glad the Pope’s visit went fairly well and I hope he makes the most of it because with public feelings running high I don’t expect he’ll be rushing to come back any time soon.


  1. 1
    SarahTX2

    Thank God, he’s gone for good. The UK was pretty charitable to him over all. Given the number of children who have killed themselves because of his dehumanizing church, he’s lucky to be alive.

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    Tony de New York

    SarahTX2 u must be thxful that u did not live under the ATHEIST dictatorship of Stalin and Mao, both of their gobernement kill, more than 100 millions human beings.

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    Matthew

    Jesus said that it would be better for someone to have a millstone hung around their neck and cast into the sea than to face the judgement they will receive for causing a little one to sin. This certainly wasn’t something Jesus viewed lightly or wanted swept under the carpet.

    I can understand why this would make people want to reject all religion but the problem isn’t organised religion but the failure of some in organised religion to take seriously and live up to the words of Jesus.

    Child abuse of any kind should not be tolerated and I hope we will be as vocal in condemning it when it occurs outside the church as it does inside it.

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    The_Glovner

    Every bloomin time there is a religiously minded follower just waiting to leap out with the non sequitar staple reply:

    What about Stalin and Mao (to be fair you missed out Hitler and Pol Pot who usually get trotted out in the same sentence).

    Try to understand the facts for a moment. Stalin, Mao (Pol Pot and Hitler) did not do what they did in the name of a lack of any belief in religion. Therefore what they did was not in the name of atheism.

    The only requirement to be an atheist is that you lack belief in religion (and some would also add supernatural to that).

    They did what they did in the name of power. The same can’t be said for attrocities carried out in the name of a religion (not just yours though).

    If you think what they did was done in the name of athiesm it is just as likely that there is a 50/50 chance with Mao, Pol Pot, Stalin and Hitler that the crimes were carried out because half of them had a moustache, must be a frightening world for you to live in with all those evil hairy top lipped devils out there.

    Report abuse

  5. 5
    Colin.D.

    Typical god squad reply from Matthew. All right minded people abhor child abuse wherever it takes place and will speak out about it. The problem is that if a bricklayer or milkman, ( examples only), is caught abusing children they are brought to court and publicly exposed in their crime and prosecuted, whereas if it’s a priest, the powers that be do all in their power to hush it up. Therefore this ridiculous pope is responsible for these cover-ups as head of his church and, I believe by definition, he is condoning these crimes. Those responsible should be named, shamed and banged up for years for what they did and then they would have got off lightly.
    Religion is built on a myth anyway. The sight of all those bishops and cardinals etc. dressed in their party frocks and trying to look pious had me in stitches. All that pomp and ceremony to sing the praises of an imaginary deity. You’d get the same result praying to the great god of the M25 for a clear run at 7-30am round Heathrow.

    Report abuse



Free e-Supplements

TWITTER

Shropshire Star on Twitter Shropshire Star on Twitter

Keep updated with the latest breaking news and content on our Twitter feed.

Lifestyle

Interactive Dining Out map Interactive Dining Out map

Hundreds of reviews by the Shropshire Star and Express & Star's teams to help you decide where to eat.

Entertainment

All the film reviews All the film reviews

Before you plan a trip to the pictures, get our critics' verdicts on all the latest movie releases.

OUR NEW APP

Get the new Shropshire Star app Get the new Shropshire Star app

Download the Shropshire Star’s new app to your iPad or iPhone to get one week of access to our digital newspapers absolutely FREE.